Barbara Rosenberg is dying. we aren't sure what it is, but we know it's terminal. she is hopped up on OxyContin. she is in the care of her son. she is telling the story of her life.
-#-it's a character study, in other words, of what turns out to be a remarkably unpleasant woman that has sewn herself up in disappointment over not getting the life she dreamed for herself. she is unhappy with her husband—by all appearances a mild-mannered, relatively kind-hearted man—for not going into a career that would make him (and therefore her) lots of money. she's unhappy with her former best friend for being successful where she herself isn't and for a betrayal she spends the better part of the book dancing around. and most of all she is furious with her son for daring to be trans.
all the holes in the shallow foundation of transphobia are exposed (though it takes little to expose them). it's nothing more, here, than an unhappy woman wanting absolute control over someone else. the thing about other people, though, is that they will be stubbornly themselves. (don't have a child if you're not prepared for that.)
all the holes in the shallow foundation of transphobia are exposed (though it takes little to expose them). it's nothing more, here, than an unhappy woman wanting absolute control over someone else. the thing about other people, though, is that they will be stubbornly themselves. (don't have a child if you're not prepared for that.)
it's someone who is incapable of any kind of curiosity about somebody else's inner experience, incapable of ever trying to understand it or even having the thought that there might be something to understand.
as so many transphobes do, she makes a fetish of gender all on her own: she's obsessed with her own womanhood, with her husband's manhood (and his failure to live up to what she feels it ought to be), with the womanhood of others (a recurrent strand throughout the novel is that she once worked at a plastic surgeon's office). she is obsessed with the idea of existing within the male/female binary.
get past the pathologizing. put aside the stereotypical ideas of gender. what you find is that it's not just trans people, it's cis people, too, that have a complex slew of desires around gender and perception.
-#-
she swings, as this kind of person so often does, between grandiose superiority and unhappy self-doubt. either, never mind both, are enough to forestall a substantive human connection—and it's hard to say, indeed, whether Barbara Rosenberg has one or not. she walks up, at one point, to the line of epiphany, exposes a bit of vulnerability—and then, just as swiftly, snaps back and retreats, returns to lashing out and to distrust. indeed, she doubles down on it.
there is no grand revelation of some terrible childhood trauma in her past to make her this way. there isn't.
as so many transphobes do, she makes a fetish of gender all on her own: she's obsessed with her own womanhood, with her husband's manhood (and his failure to live up to what she feels it ought to be), with the womanhood of others (a recurrent strand throughout the novel is that she once worked at a plastic surgeon's office). she is obsessed with the idea of existing within the male/female binary.
get past the pathologizing. put aside the stereotypical ideas of gender. what you find is that it's not just trans people, it's cis people, too, that have a complex slew of desires around gender and perception.
-#-
she swings, as this kind of person so often does, between grandiose superiority and unhappy self-doubt. either, never mind both, are enough to forestall a substantive human connection—and it's hard to say, indeed, whether Barbara Rosenberg has one or not. she walks up, at one point, to the line of epiphany, exposes a bit of vulnerability—and then, just as swiftly, snaps back and retreats, returns to lashing out and to distrust. indeed, she doubles down on it.
there is no grand revelation of some terrible childhood trauma in her past to make her this way. there isn't.
there are a handful of thoughts that can be deeply tempting: first, that suffering is redemptive. second, that anybody who suffers will bring it upon another. third, that anybody who is awful must have been wounded to make them that way.
none of this is true.
none of this is true.
there is no virtue in pain.
to be sure, if somebody only knows a particular kind of poison, then chances are—unless they work at it, unless they are very self-aware, unless they have outside help—that they will, more than likely, reproduce it, but this is not inevitable. and she creates a fresh poison all on her own.
and, finally, there is no grand wound to make her this way. it took nothing more than the ordinary, run-of-the-mill disappointments that being a person in the world necessarily entails, the self-deception that existing as a consciousness and a self brings, and the particular narcissism that emerges from insecurity, to curdle her. Barbara Rosenberg just isn't a very nice person.
-#-
with that said, however, she is often a very funny person. her pieties to cruelty are wicked sharp. her horror at lesbianism—which she returns to with entertaining circularity—is very funny.
but make no mistake. it is cruelty. she never once acknowledges her son as her son; dying brings no epiphanies to Barbara Rosenberg. her son is never clearly sketched—even a handful of diary entries from when he is in his mid-twenties, before he transitions, don't give us a clear image of him—and so he is a presence carved from an absence, a lacunae in Barbara's perspective. through the addlement of opioids she sees him not even as a person but a bird-like creature.
and she returns, again and again, to the corduroy blazer he wants when he is young. please don't mistake the blazer: it's a stand-in, but it's not for his relationship to gender. it's a stand-in for hers and for the way that hers requires control over his.
and, finally, there is no grand wound to make her this way. it took nothing more than the ordinary, run-of-the-mill disappointments that being a person in the world necessarily entails, the self-deception that existing as a consciousness and a self brings, and the particular narcissism that emerges from insecurity, to curdle her. Barbara Rosenberg just isn't a very nice person.
-#-
with that said, however, she is often a very funny person. her pieties to cruelty are wicked sharp. her horror at lesbianism—which she returns to with entertaining circularity—is very funny.
but make no mistake. it is cruelty. she never once acknowledges her son as her son; dying brings no epiphanies to Barbara Rosenberg. her son is never clearly sketched—even a handful of diary entries from when he is in his mid-twenties, before he transitions, don't give us a clear image of him—and so he is a presence carved from an absence, a lacunae in Barbara's perspective. through the addlement of opioids she sees him not even as a person but a bird-like creature.
and she returns, again and again, to the corduroy blazer he wants when he is young. please don't mistake the blazer: it's a stand-in, but it's not for his relationship to gender. it's a stand-in for hers and for the way that hers requires control over his.
in Marx's Capital, the coat is presented as the generic example of a commodity which effaces the labor that inheres in it as a creation of labor. here, the corduroy blazer acts like a commodity-representation of gender. gender, accumulating, as capital does, through its artefacts and residues in the world: the visible secondary sex characteristic (the generously over-proportioned mansion), the invisible internal endocrine and reproductive systems (the socioeconomic freedom to do what you like), and the social role occupied by the possessor and the ways other perceive them for it.
the coat : capital :: the blazer : gender. a great in-joke, if you're paying attention to it.
-#-
Barbara's voice hovers somewhere between the discomfortingly candid and the tactically evasive. she renders her judgments of gender with great force; and, equally, never acknowledges her son as her son. indeed, she is divorced from his personhood entirely. the only register she can recognize that some change has taken place is through the persistent hallucination that he is a bird.
"the bird." "it." these pejoratives follow him throughout the novel. it doesn't take long to make evident that these referents are merely the most recent instantiations of Barbara's boundless inability to exercise a mote of kindness or sympathy toward him. (by the end she succumbs entirely to this hallucination—and alongside the late-in-the-day revelation of how she fell out with her best friend—and this lets us, at last, to find the reason for the book's title, which seems at odds with the contents almost to the end.)
it's petty, it's small, it's mean. it's stupid, too; but then cruelty is so often a form of stupidity. despite that, though, at the end of her life, she is shown remarkable kindness—her son, whom she depends on, still cares for her, even as she tells people that "the bird is trying to murder me." her best friend reappears one last time, too, exercising a little bit of grace. husband Stephen, so loathed, dead years before the novel, seems to remain mild up till the end.
-#-
three miscellaneous comments here.
first: this book is also deeply about Jewishness, about the twentieth-century Jewish diasporic experience. Barbara returns to Exodus again and again—don't worry, you don't need to have seen it, one doesn't get the impression that Barbara paid close attention to it herself. she's not a deep thinker. but I don't have much to say about this. I'm not Jewish, nor am I diasporic—though given how the USian government has been targeting and treating trans people, that may change—so I can't comment much.
second: the biggest weakness the book has is the ideological trellis. discussions of Marx and Marxism appear a few times, and this is justified within the text that Barbara apparently worked for Noam Chomsky as an assistant; this odd note is all there is to explain why this conservative, bourgeoise woman can comment of Marxism. it feels, to be frank, shoehorned.
third: this book is stream-of-consciousness, not in the sense of presenting pure and unfiltered thought (syntax, punctuation, spelling is all intact) but in that it follows Barbara's free-association, jumping chronologically, disemboguing into digressions and tangents. it also, structurally, jumps from Barbara's recollections of her past to shorter, diaristic (and, format-wise, italicized) entries from the present, right up to the end when it briefly breaks off for a couple of the son's diary entries (as mentioned before).
-#-
there is a reader for whom this must be deeply cathartic. I am certain it must have been deeply cathartic to write it: it is autobiographical in nature. note the name, Rosenberg, shared by the author and by the mother/son of the novel. note the name, Jordy, and the son's deadname, and his present-day reference as J. the author is, himself, a trans man! this autobiographical layer adds yet another layer of richness. it gives the text the brilliant ring of truth, because it comes from first-hand experience, it comes from what must have been a difficult, herculean feat of empathy and of trying to understand.
by telling the story of this bitter, hateful, homophobic, transphobic, Zionist woman—permanently disappointed, permanently bitter, trying to vicariously live the womanhood she never got through her son—through her own eyes, it exposes the banality and mundanity of those views.
"intellectual" writing and politicians alike enjoy constructing elaborate edifices of justification around views that boil down, ultimately, to nothing more or less than hate. it is okay for some people—because they are poor, because they are the wrong gender, because they have the wrong skin color, because they are disabled, because they want to change gender and sex—to suffer.
most people, though, don't really have access to all that theory. they have their small, petty prejudices and they have their absurd, stupid self-justifications. they have lacunae they willfully refuse to improve upon.
there is nothing more to hate than that.
the coat : capital :: the blazer : gender. a great in-joke, if you're paying attention to it.
-#-
Barbara's voice hovers somewhere between the discomfortingly candid and the tactically evasive. she renders her judgments of gender with great force; and, equally, never acknowledges her son as her son. indeed, she is divorced from his personhood entirely. the only register she can recognize that some change has taken place is through the persistent hallucination that he is a bird.
"the bird." "it." these pejoratives follow him throughout the novel. it doesn't take long to make evident that these referents are merely the most recent instantiations of Barbara's boundless inability to exercise a mote of kindness or sympathy toward him. (by the end she succumbs entirely to this hallucination—and alongside the late-in-the-day revelation of how she fell out with her best friend—and this lets us, at last, to find the reason for the book's title, which seems at odds with the contents almost to the end.)
it's petty, it's small, it's mean. it's stupid, too; but then cruelty is so often a form of stupidity. despite that, though, at the end of her life, she is shown remarkable kindness—her son, whom she depends on, still cares for her, even as she tells people that "the bird is trying to murder me." her best friend reappears one last time, too, exercising a little bit of grace. husband Stephen, so loathed, dead years before the novel, seems to remain mild up till the end.
-#-
three miscellaneous comments here.
first: this book is also deeply about Jewishness, about the twentieth-century Jewish diasporic experience. Barbara returns to Exodus again and again—don't worry, you don't need to have seen it, one doesn't get the impression that Barbara paid close attention to it herself. she's not a deep thinker. but I don't have much to say about this. I'm not Jewish, nor am I diasporic—though given how the USian government has been targeting and treating trans people, that may change—so I can't comment much.
second: the biggest weakness the book has is the ideological trellis. discussions of Marx and Marxism appear a few times, and this is justified within the text that Barbara apparently worked for Noam Chomsky as an assistant; this odd note is all there is to explain why this conservative, bourgeoise woman can comment of Marxism. it feels, to be frank, shoehorned.
third: this book is stream-of-consciousness, not in the sense of presenting pure and unfiltered thought (syntax, punctuation, spelling is all intact) but in that it follows Barbara's free-association, jumping chronologically, disemboguing into digressions and tangents. it also, structurally, jumps from Barbara's recollections of her past to shorter, diaristic (and, format-wise, italicized) entries from the present, right up to the end when it briefly breaks off for a couple of the son's diary entries (as mentioned before).
-#-
there is a reader for whom this must be deeply cathartic. I am certain it must have been deeply cathartic to write it: it is autobiographical in nature. note the name, Rosenberg, shared by the author and by the mother/son of the novel. note the name, Jordy, and the son's deadname, and his present-day reference as J. the author is, himself, a trans man! this autobiographical layer adds yet another layer of richness. it gives the text the brilliant ring of truth, because it comes from first-hand experience, it comes from what must have been a difficult, herculean feat of empathy and of trying to understand.
by telling the story of this bitter, hateful, homophobic, transphobic, Zionist woman—permanently disappointed, permanently bitter, trying to vicariously live the womanhood she never got through her son—through her own eyes, it exposes the banality and mundanity of those views.
"intellectual" writing and politicians alike enjoy constructing elaborate edifices of justification around views that boil down, ultimately, to nothing more or less than hate. it is okay for some people—because they are poor, because they are the wrong gender, because they have the wrong skin color, because they are disabled, because they want to change gender and sex—to suffer.
most people, though, don't really have access to all that theory. they have their small, petty prejudices and they have their absurd, stupid self-justifications. they have lacunae they willfully refuse to improve upon.
there is nothing more to hate than that.
No comments:
Post a Comment